2 May 2022

378

Espinoza vs. Schulenburg

Format: APA

Academic level: College

Paper type: Case Study

Words: 294

Pages: 1

Downloads: 0

Espinoza, a firefighter and emergency medical technician was wounded while providing roadside assistance to the Schulenburgs. Although she was off-duty, she felt obliged to offer assistance to the Schulenburgs who were victims at the accident scene. Since she was injured, Espinoza afterwards brought up legal action, which involved the Schulenburgs as respondents as enshrined in the rescue doctrine. At the trial court, the judge held that the fireman’s rule prohibited Espinoza from trying to enforce responsibility on the Schulenburgs and discharged them as defendants. However, emphasis is on enforcing the code that in Arizona, the fireman’s rule as an exemption to the rule of liability revealed in the rescue doctrine is to be narrowly applied (Kessler, 2006).. As such, the fireman’s rule will not block an off-duty firefighter from pursuing recovery for wounds sustained while carrying out a rescue or providing assistance.

With the due consideration on the exemption to the rule of liability, the Arizona Supreme Court distinguished between on-duty and off duty. Off-duty applies where the firefighter renders assistance but is faced with a greater risk of harm than while on-duty. That such an individual makes a voluntary effort to assist the victims without the motivation of being paid. Furthermore, an off-duty firefighter has the option of choosing to assist or not (State case files. (n.d.). However, the on-duty firefighter has an obligation to offer assistance as mandated by the departmental policies or their employment code. 

It’s time to jumpstart your paper!

Delegate your assignment to our experts and they will do the rest.

Get custom essay

In conclusion, the department addresses rendering aid off duty as a personal choice. That off-duty is not part of my “duty” as a firefighter, but rather more so an ethical duty. In light of this, the department addresses off duty injuries incurred as a result of rendering aid as worth compensating. It places off-duty firefighters on the same legal balance as a normal civilian volunteer, maintaining that the firefighter is under no service obligation to stopover and provide aid. 

References

Bennett, L. T. (2008). Fire service law . Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.

Kessler, D. (2006). Arizona Court of Appeals. Appellate Highlights . Arizona Attorney. 

State case files. (n.d.). In The Court of Appeals State of Arizona Division One . Retrieved on April 15, 2018. http://statecasefiles.justia.com/documents/arizona/court-of-appeals-division-one-published/CV040438.pdf  

Illustration
Cite this page

Select style:

Reference

StudyBounty. (2023, September 16). Espinoza vs. Schulenburg.
https://studybounty.com/espinoza-vs-schulenburg-case-study

illustration

Related essays

We post free essay examples for college on a regular basis. Stay in the know!

Cruel and Unusual Punishments

Since the beginning of society, human behaviour has remained to be explained by the social forces that take control. Be it negative or positive, the significance of social forces extend to explain the behaviour of...

Words: 1329

Pages: 5

Views: 104

Serial Killers Phenomena: The Predisposing Factors

CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION _Background information _ Ronald and Stephen Holmes in their article _Contemporary Perspective on Serial Murder_ define a serial killer as anyone who murders more than 3 people in a span...

Words: 3648

Pages: 14

Views: 441

Patent Protection Problem

A patent offers inventors the right for a limited period to prevent other people from using or sharing an invention without their authorization. When a patent right is granted to inventors, they are given a limited...

Words: 1707

Pages: 6

Views: 275

General Aspects of Nonprofit Organizations

Nonprofit organizations are prone to the long and tedious legal process of start-up as compared to their for-profit organizations. However, there are similar rules that govern the startup and the existence of both...

Words: 294

Pages: 1

Views: 73

Contract Performance, Breach, and Remedies: Contract Discharge

1\. State whether you conclude the Amended Warehouse Lease is enforceable by Guettinger, or alternatively, whether the Amended Warehouse Lease is null and void, and Smith, therefore, does not have to pay the full...

Words: 291

Pages: 1

Views: 134

US Customs Border Control

Introduction The United States Border Patrol is the federal security law enforcement agency with the task to protect America from illegal immigrants, terrorism and the weapons of mass destruction from entering...

Words: 1371

Pages: 7

Views: 118

illustration

Running out of time?

Entrust your assignment to proficient writers and receive TOP-quality paper before the deadline is over.

Illustration