According to the article ‘Inside Pete Buttigieg’s Plan to Overhaul the Supreme Court’ the justice system, specifically, the Supreme Court is controlled by political ideologies. The justice system has become politicized as a rift is witnessed between the political affiliates of the Democratic and Republican parties (Lederman, 2019). Justices in the Supreme Court make rulings based on their political affiliations, thus obstructing the attainment of justice for citizens that do not conform to a particular ideology. Pete Buttigieg, a potential presidential candidate in the 2020 elections, proposes ways in which this system may be depoliticized.
One of the pros of this article is that it highlights the methods proposed by Buttigieg that will be used to reform the justice system. The method includes electing 15 justices to the Supreme Court, with the Republicans and Democrats each having five judges (Lederman, 2019). The remaining five justices will be chosen by the 10 and are required to be apolitical for there to be comprehensive reform in the justice system (Lederman, 2019). The article also further articulates how such a move might reinforce political affiliations in the Supreme Court as it would be difficult to tell a democratic judge from a Republican one. Moreover, the implementation of this move would require an amendment to the constitution to alter the election of justices, which is currently done based on appointment by the president. The article highlights how this implementation would affect the Supreme Court. However, the author of the article fails in its introduction, whereby he begins the article with references to abortion. Such an introduction misleads the reader into thinking that the material is on abortion. This setback inhibits the impact of the article on an audience interested in the recent abortion laws.
Delegate your assignment to our experts and they will do the rest.
In conclusion, the article highlights the injustices in the Supreme Court and how the infiltration of politics has damaged the Supreme Court. It also highlights a proposed amendment to the constitution that would see the Supreme Court depoliticized. The article should, therefore, have focused on the politicizing of the justice system, so as not to mislead readers.
References
Lederman, J. (2019). Inside Pete Buttigieg’s plan to overhaul the Supreme Court. Retrieved from https://www.nbcnews.com/news/amp/ncna1012491
