I agree with Dr. Reynolds's response concerning free market reproduction. The market itself is free of prejudice, however, people put up their own biases employing demand and supply which supports the market and keeps it alive. We can impose or soothe prohibitions since our aim is not to change the elemental operation of the free market, which then results in imposing desired ethics. Dr. Reynolds's affirmation about the need for restrictions on some marketing decisions is an acknowledgment that the market should be seen as a means to convey ethical decisions. For instance, people might cut down cider trees upon hearing that the wood can be used for house decor. The destruction of ciders will then be blamed directly on the demand for ciders and not the market which merely facilitates the buying and selling of cider wood.
Dr. Reynolds's reasoning of a market regulation also appeals to me as convincing. She talks about assisted reproduction where many ethical issues arise. Assisted reproduction involves third parties who undergo in vitro fertilization, for females to increase egg reproduction or artificial insemination for males ( Shalev, Moreno, Eyal, Leibel, Schuz, & Eldar-Geva, 2016). The eggs and sperms are then harvested, fused, and inserted in the infertile woman's uterus. Ethical issues may arise if the third party persons are asked to pay for their treatment yet they are donors.
Delegate your assignment to our experts and they will do the rest.
Another ethical issue is the fertility treatment cost which is normally very expensive and in most cases not covered by any insurance policies. Low income earning couples that are unable to conceive naturally are greatly disadvantaged as they are left with limited or no options at all. Ethically, prohibitions can be put against the overpricing of the treatments so that most families can afford it. This does not affect the market at all.
References
de Waal, E., Vrooman, L. A., Fischer, E., Ord, T., Mainigi, M. A., Coutifaris, C., ... & Bartolomei, M. S. (2015). The cumulative effect of assisted reproduction procedures on placental development and epigenetic perturbations in a mouse model. Human molecular
genetics , 24 (24), 6975-6985.
Shalev, C., Moreno, A., Eyal, H., Leibel, M., Schuz, R., & Eldar-Geva, T. (2016). Ethics and regulation of inter-country medically assisted reproduction: a call for action. Israel journal of health policy research , 5 (1), 59.
