12 Apr 2022


DCS Sanitation Management v. Eloy Castillo

Format: APA

Academic level: College

Paper type: Case Study

Words: 565

Pages: 2

Downloads: 0

Hiring of DCS employees by Packers

The hiring of the DCS employees by Packers Sanitation Services, Inc. does not seem to be ethical. This is particularly so as the organization took on three employees from a close competitor in a bid to take over the new cleaning contract. This contract had just been received after a bidding process between the Tyson processing plant and the competing cleaning services companies (Moran, 2014). It is evident that the employment of the DCS employees may have been unethical as they were key workers in the various processes involved in the cleaning and staffing processes of the former company. The employees may be able to provide the close competitors of DCS with trade secrets on how to ensure that the owners of Tyson plant are completely satisfied (Moran, 2014). This way, the Packer’s company will be able to hold on to this new client for as long as possible. The Packers organization is seen to look for alternative ways that it could be able to ensure that DCS does not continue its reign as cleaning and sanitation service providers to the plant. Packers sanitation services will only be able to do this once they have captured top employees who were hands on involved in the core processes of cleaning the processing plant.

Non-Compete Agreements

Non-compete agreements serve as a means of preventing employees who have terminated their contracts with the organization from providing the knowledge they learnt during their employment to direct competitors. Alternatively, the agreement serves as a means of preventing former employees from opening similar businesses and consequently snatching away clients that were once involved with the company. However, organizations that provide cleaning and sanitation services to buildings, it should not be a necessary requirement that personnel be required to sign non-compete agreements. This is particularly for the employees involved in the cleaning process of the building as they are merely conducting the service and not involved in various trade secrets. Alternatively, higher ranking staff members may be required to sign non-compete agreements that will ensure the individual is not in direct competition with their former employer. These higher ranking employees include those that are directly involved in the mixing of solutions that are used in the cleaning process. This may also involve a case where the solutions used are produced by the company. Hereby, the employees who are involved in cleaning will not be informed of the composition of the mixture as a means of ensuring the trade secret is maintained to only a few.

It’s time to jumpstart your paper!

Delegate your assignment to our experts and they will do the rest.

Get custom essay

Ethics in Resolution of Case

The DCS Sanitation Management was suing three of its former employees for breaching non-compete agreement, disclosing trade secrets and sensitive information and breaching their contracts. The plaintiff in this case sought to urge these former employees based on the non-compete agreements that they had signed earlier, money damages and instructing them not to disclose confidential information to their new employer. Hereby, the plaintiff in this case sought for a preliminary judgment while the defendants sought a summary judgment. The court ruled in favor of the defendants as it denied the plaintiffs motion. This is seen an ethical resolution of the case as the plaintiffs failed to demonstrate that the former employees had breached contract by signing on with a direct competitor. The DCS organization also failed to file an appeal against the former employees and the decision of the district courts resulting in the end of the stated periods within the non-compete agreements. This would make the appeal to be moot.


DCS Sanitation Management v. Eloy Castillo, No. 05-1201, US Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit, 2006, Web.

Moran, J. J. (2014). Employment law: New challenges in the business environment (6th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall

Cite this page

Select style:


StudyBounty. (2023, September 15). DCS Sanitation Management v. Eloy Castillo.


Related essays

We post free essay examples for college on a regular basis. Stay in the know!

How AI Can Help Retailers Solve Business Problems

The global marketplace is currently more integrated than ever before. This situation presents a never-before experienced opportunity for retailers. Multinational organizations whose sole basis is the internet have...

Words: 2700

Pages: 5

Views: 138

The Natural Organizational Model and the Informal Groups

The nature of an organization is based on different factors such as the environment it is set up in. also, the type of activity it undertakes. This paper will examine the natural organizational model, the informal...

Words: 3009

Pages: 10

Views: 240

Why Pinkberry should focus on making orange and yellow the two prevailing colours

The fact that Pinkberry has evolved from a storefront to a nationally recognized brand makes this franchise of frozen dessert yogurt shops an example to be followed. Yes, the personality of a brand created a platform...

Words: 582

Pages: 2

Views: 94

Ford Motors: Board Presentation For Electric and Hybrid cars Production

Executive Summary The motor vehicle industry in America and worldwide is highly competitive with major players no longer enjoying the dominance that they had had before. Innovation and identification of trends...

Words: 1088

Pages: 4

Views: 130

Home Remodel Project Plan

Project Overview Home remodeling is one of the notable key projects undertake through project management, as a project manager is expected to come up with a clear plan that would help in meeting the expected...

Words: 2152

Pages: 8

Views: 69

How Airbnb Achieved Success

Hospitality industry includes firms that provide lodging and dining services for customers. Many of the businesses in the travel and hospitality industry offer customers with prepared meals, accommodation, snacks,...

Words: 906

Pages: 3

Views: 63


Running out of time?

Entrust your assignment to proficient writers and receive TOP-quality paper before the deadline is over.