Public nuisance laws are seen as discriminatory. The argument is that the effect of these rules on victims of domestic violence is disproportionate. Indeed, nuisance laws seem to have a negative effect on women as they are the biggest victims of domestic violence.
The issue of determining whether a tenant is a nuisance is founded on the idea of how often law enforcement agencies receive a call to go resolve cases of domestic violence. If a victim reports a case of domestic violence to the police too many times, this victim (irrespective of whether their attacker lives in the house) is under threat of being systematically described as a nuisance (Desmond, 2016). Such an occurrence can prevent the victims of domestic violence from seeking the help they require; they will act on the fear that they risk eviction and thus face homelessness. Whereas not all victims of domestic violence are women, the fact is that most of them are, and the nuisance laws may infringe upon the safeguards awarded to them in Violence Against Women Acts (VAWA) and Fair Housing Act (FHA). On that note, nuisance laws may prevent victims of domestic violence, particularly women, from getting the justice they deserve due to the fear of being displaced.
Delegate your assignment to our experts and they will do the rest.
Overall, while nuisance play a key role, they are largely discriminatory and unwarranted. Their negative effect is particularly felt by women who are victims of domestic violence. The laws place them in a susceptible position since they fear reporting incidences of violence will leave them homeless. As a result, they remain in a perpetual cycle of violence that can lead to detrimental effects.
References
Desmond, M. (2016). Evicted: Poverty and Profit in the American City . Broadway books.
