5 Nov 2022

85

Pay for Performance in Public Schools Remains Controversial

Format: APA

Academic level: University

Paper type: Essay (Any Type)

Words: 783

Pages: 3

Downloads: 0

Question 1 

By instituting pay-for-performance plans within organizations, it is possible to measure their effectiveness. One of the major ways would revolve around assessing the evaluation forms, which might be differentiated by groups of employees when needed. In these instances, the evaluation forms need to portray the rating options available for every goal and category clearly together with the overall ratings. Furthermore, the forms need to define the distinct things constituting the rating or performance levels clearly, such as what constitutes outstanding performance for a specific goal. It should also define the tasks that an employee should undertake to be deemed outstanding clearly. Furthermore, measuring the effectiveness of the pay-for-performance plays should evaluate the handbook for managers or the administrative manual. This needs to serve as something, which the managers can reference to make sure that the evaluations they undertake progress efficiently (HR Daily Advisor, 2013) . The guidebooks also offer the rules for the continuing effectiveness and administration.

Moreover, measuring the effectiveness of the pay-for-performance plans need focusing on the initial as well as continuing training. The effectiveness of these programs need consistent and continuous HR training at primary points, such as the initial time the organization introduced the plan, the changing of the plan, and the time that the employees attain promotion to managerial positions. Here, the HR also needs to ensure to monitor the effectiveness of the managers in utilizing the programs while at the same time having refresher-training programs to remind the managers concerning the process. Effective pay-for-performance programs also portray efficient communication channels. Communications needs to take place both from the senior executives, to managers, and from the supervisors to the staff (HR Daily Advisor, 2013) . Communications need to be both verbal and written with the management playing a critical role during the process, while serving as an interpreter, liaison, and problem-solver.

It’s time to jumpstart your paper!

Delegate your assignment to our experts and they will do the rest.

Get custom essay

The effectiveness of a pay-for-performance plan also prevails when it portrays continuing coaching as well as feedback. It is not possible to base pay-for-performance programs solely based on yearly performance evaluations. Ongoing conversations should prevail to keep supporting the program in line with ensuring that the employees keep developing during the entire year. The effectiveness in this case also needs to revolve around ongoing coaching and feedback. With ongoing coaching as well as feedback between the managers and the workforce during the performance period, it becomes possible to ensure that the workers remain on track. These sessions also make sure that managers encourage appropriate behaviors by offering positive feedback in line with providing coaching, which addresses areas that might require improvement (HR Daily Advisor, 2013) . The ultimate goal is to boost performance during the year while at the same time minimizing chances of surprises during review meetings.

Question 2 

From the employees’ perspective, utilizing pay-for-performance plans presents certain disadvantage. For instance, it might result to deteriorating quality. These plans might lead the workforce to lay considerable emphasis on quantity rather than quality, which would result to quality deterioration. For example, salespersons devoted to generating as much increased sales as possible to allow them to realize bonuses might fail to focus on details, including proper filling of paper work or ensuring that a product exists in stock prior to placing the order. In this sense, the consumers would end up receiving incorrect items or lead to increased wait times for delivery unlike the salesperson promised (Joseph, 2019) . This would lead the employees to be discredited for poor quality of work.

An additional drawback attributed to pay-for-performance plans relates to the insufficient motivation generated in the workplace. In the event that the workforces receive significantly low incentives amount, they lack the motivation needed to allow them to reach the anticipated levels of productivity. The workforces might end up even resenting the employers for failing to provide meaningful programs, which would have major impact toward their living standards (Joseph, 2019) . In this sense, they would be motivated to perform only minimum levels of work, which would be adequate to retaining employment while regarding extra effort as time wastage.

Question 3 

From the perspective of the employer, the pay-for-performance plan has certain disadvantages. For instance, it presents hindrances when measuring performance. Unless the standards of performance are entirely objective, including when awarding sales people bonuses for attaining predetermined levels of sales, challenges might emerge in determining whether the performance requires the incentive availed. This imposes pressures on supervisors when undertaking performance appraisals to make sure that they assess the performance of every employee accurately (Petersen, 2019) . For most supervisors, they are known to have a tendency of offering inflated appraisals to make sure that the workforces realize their incentives.

The pay-for-performance program also disadvantageous in that it leads to reduced teamwork among the employees. For the employees embarking on ways of reaching their goals, they sometimes show less willingness in working as teams. They show hesitance in offering assistance who colleagues experience challenges in their tasks since they perceive the act as a means of wasting valuable time. They would rather utilize the time improving their individual productivity (Petersen, 2019) . In certain cases, conflict between the workforces emerges due to lack of collaboration or the idea of one employee limiting another from realizing set objectives.

References

HR Daily Advisor. (2013). 5 components of an effective pay-for-performance program. Retrieved from https://hrdailyadvisor.blr.com/2013/07/24/5-components-of-an-effective-pay-for-performance-program/

Joseph, C. (2019). The disadvantages of pay for performance. Retrieved from https://bizfluent.com/info-8652434-disadvantages-pay-performance.html

Petersen, L. (2019). Advantages & disadvantages of pay-for-performance policies. Retrieved from https://smallbusiness.chron.com/advantages-disadvantages-payforperformance-policies-44264.html

Illustration
Cite this page

Select style:

Reference

StudyBounty. (2023, September 15). Pay for Performance in Public Schools Remains Controversial.
https://studybounty.com/pay-for-performance-in-public-schools-remains-controversial-essay

illustration

Related essays

We post free essay examples for college on a regular basis. Stay in the know!

17 Sep 2023
HRM

Leadership Profile Part III: How to Be an Effective Leader

Psychologists have made significant contributions in the business sphere by outlining primary traits of accredited leaders. Organizations have administered psychological tests to identify features that are most...

Words: 1121

Pages: 4

Views: 434

17 Sep 2023
HRM

Key Concepts Exercise: Implication for Managers

In a unitary perspective on the staff-management relationship in an organization, the staff, as well as management, is interlinked in the combined effort of achieving a unified purpose which is often the success of...

Words: 519

Pages: 2

Views: 87

17 Sep 2023
HRM

Alignment of the Talent Needs with M.J’s Business Strategy

Information technology (IT) is offering a wide range of opportunities and great potential in the banking industry. According to Madhushree, Radhakrishnan, and Aithal (2018), IT enables the banking sectors to...

Words: 1434

Pages: 5

Views: 372

17 Sep 2023
HRM

Values in the Human Services Profession

The human service profession was developed in the year 1960 with the intentions of responding to the needs of people together to the various problems affecting them. Moreover, the business is characterized by...

Words: 896

Pages: 3

Views: 94

17 Sep 2023
HRM

The Pay-For-Performance (P4P) Principle In Healthcare

The pay-for-performance (P4P) is a central idea in the healthcare dialogue as it proposes that patient should base their payments based on the quality of services they receive. There are four measurements that one...

Words: 368

Pages: 1

Views: 177

17 Sep 2023
HRM

Human Capital Plan: How to Create a Human Capital Plan

People are the most crucial asset in organizations. Often, organization leaders are aware of this, but only a few compliment it with actions. To ensure that focused action can enhance the achievement of organization...

Words: 2499

Pages: 9

Views: 440

illustration

Running out of time?

Entrust your assignment to proficient writers and receive TOP-quality paper before the deadline is over.

Illustration