Support for differences in Piaget and Vygotsky Theories
Jean Piaget and Lev Vygotsky offered explanations about children's learning abilities styles based on their level of cognition. However, their views differ since Piaget asserts that cognitive development is an immutable four-phase process that follows a sequence of age-related periods ("2. 2 Piaget"). Piaget thus concluded that each child strives for cognitive equilibrium, a stage where one develops mental concepts of his or her experiences. On the other hand, Vygotsky believed that a child does not have autonomy in the learning process since he or she internalizes what is acceptable in his or her culture ("2.3 Vygotsky"). This assertion means that the child is an apprentice who learns through scaffolding that adults facilitate. Piaget and Vygotsky may have different views on how children learn, but their theories are relevant, considering that they offer suggestions for designing a developmentally appropriate curriculum.
Combining Piaget's and Vygotsky's Theories to Provide A More Valid Account of Real-Life Development
Delegate your assignment to our experts and they will do the rest.
Piaget's and Vygotsky's theories have contradicting stances regarding children's cognitive development, but they can be integrated to improve outcomes. Essentially, children should be exposed to age-appropriate learning through hands-on projects and experiments, as proposed by Piaget. At the same time, children should be allowed to communicate and interact with others in the cultural context and environment to facilitate learning. Social interactions are crucial since they help children adapt to individualized thinking ("2.3 Vygotsky"). The insistence on individualized thinking is a central theme in Piaget's theory, but it cannot occur without the assistance of others through scaffolding.
Example of a Child Illustrating Piaget's Idea of a Child as a Scientist
Piaget concluded that a child is a scientist capable of experimenting with concepts and applying deductive reasoning. For instance, a child who adds and subtracts a zero from any number and knows that it does not affect the outcome is a scientist by Piaget's definition.
Description of a Situation Where Vygotsky's Theory is Being Demonstrated
Vygotsky advanced the idea of scaffolding where adults assist children in internalizing concepts beyond their mental age. This concept can be demonstrated when a teacher asks a student to collaborate with a caregiver or parent in a class project. This collaboration means that the parent being knowledgeable will assist the student in learning new concepts that align with one's culture.
References
2.2. Piaget
2.3 Vygotsky
