In 2011, Alabama passed some laws restricting immigrants from conducting business as usual in the employment sector. The law instituted prohibits all employers based in the region from intentionally hiring undocumented immigrants who have previously provided a cheap labor source to farmers. The law's primary role was to restrict employers from firing or rejecting American citizen workers while hosting undocumented immigrants as workers and held this as a discriminatory practice. It was coupled with severe tax consequences for employers who are found violating the law. Despite undocumented immigrants becoming a recently rising policy issue, this was not the best means to tackle the challenge by use of state laws. State rulings have a high likelihood of making biased decisions; thus, I felt this was not the best way to address the policy issue (“ Student Loans: More Debt, More Defaults, More Problems," 2012 ). Workers have continuously benefited from immigrants' cheap labor; some immigrants come from Mexico, among other countries. Typically, the provisions of the law fundamentally target regulating employers conducting business in the state of Alabama. Using the Immigration regulation law was not the best way to address the policy issue. Instead, the policy issue should have been addressed by providing law provisions that are fair to immigrants and employers. For example, a law that addresses the policy issue should ensure whites are incorporated into the program without immediately dispatching immigrants who appear to be more skilled and experienced to work in the fields. A law that allows immigrants from Mexico to travel under specific documents purposely to work for Alabama employers would have provided equal and fairgrounds without discriminating against either of the two parties involved. Regarding the Alabama state rulings, states should not be granted the authority to establish immigration laws and laws that involve foreigners. The capacity for a state to develop immigrant laws provides an opportunity to practice self-interests in the issue at hand. For instance, in the case of Alabama immigration policy, the state was exercising its powers to eliminate undocumented immigrants who in a way support the state's economy by providing traverse labor (“ For Undocumented Workers, It's Not-so-Sweet Home Alabama," 2011 ). States being allowed to develop and enforce their own laws has its merits and demerits. States should be allowed to establish and enforce their own laws, but with the federal government's assistance to ensure social justice has been fully exercised. Under the federal government's help, state governs will come up with laws that go through a review process, which involves scrutiny by the federal government, thus ensuring no baseness when establishing and implementing laws. The Alabama laws were biased on the immigrants' side since it deprived them of the right to work under Alabama state employers who gave fair compensation in wages. This shows how states are not capable of exercising transparency when enacting and implementing laws. In Alabama, when the law immediately came into effect, the state employers went shortage of workers since the locally available ones were not skilled enough to provide similar services as the immigrants previously did. One major significance was that many employers had to go to waste due to the unavailability of a sufficient labor force. On the other hand, local whites can now access local jobs. However, according to the employers, their work rate is below average compared to most immigrants who worked there initially before the law was implemented. Farmers have incurred huge losses since the law came into effect, and other farmers were forced to opt for other survival means other than farming.
References
For Undocumented Workers, It's Not-so-Sweet Home Alabama. (, 2011). [Video]. Retrieved 17 November 2020, from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZojJszoBXgI.
Delegate your assignment to our experts and they will do the rest.
Student Loans: More Debt, More Defaults, More Problems. (, 2012). [Video]. Retrieved 17 November 2020, from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6p0HyjtfaMg.
