In her post on “Brief Psychoanalytic Therapy (BPT), Mentalization and Transference, Ashley Johnson presents a contrast of how Mentalization and Transference are related to BPT regarding the three videos. The book on “Theories of Counseling and Psychotherapy” by Linda W. Seligman and Lourie W. Reichenberg (1999), argues that clinicians can impose a change on the emotional experiences, providing higher chances of insight. To some extent, I would agree with Ashley’s post that the three videos (Life Passages, Mentalization, and the transference) present physicians’ attempts to solve internal conflicts among the clients.
Typically, both Mentalization and transference consider the development of a strong relationship between the clinicians and clients. Transference in the Mentalization-based treatment covers the feelings of the clinician and response to provide according to the feelings inside them (Allen, (2013). In contrasting the two concepts, transference considers how clinicians anticipate patients’ response to test the patients’ state of mind. For instance, in the three video cases, the clinicians are spotted conducting therapeutic analyses of past and present events to ascertain the patients’ internal conflicts. According to the claims presented in the three videos, the clinicians interact with patients by asking questions to alter the emotional distress and promote mentalizing in the patients.
Delegate your assignment to our experts and they will do the rest.
However, I would present a refuting argument against Ashley’s post regarding clinicians challenging the patients’ mental state. The case against Ashley’s post is that the clinicians instead provide a clinician-patient relationship that is aimed at traces carefully whatever the clinicians say to the patients, assisting the patients to recover from their state of mind. It is practically hard to separate the two concepts of Mentalization and transference since transference is the broader aspect that covers the Mentalization-based treatment. Additionally, the book of Psalms in the Bible teaches on spiritual transference, that the relationship with God through prayer is the source of everything (Psalms 16:11).
References
Bateman, A.W., & Fonagy, P. (1999). Effectiveness of partial hospitalization in the treatment of borderline personality disorder: a randomized controlled trial. American Journal of Psychiatry
Allen, J. (2013). Mentalizing in the Development and Treatment of Attachment Trauma. London: Karnac Books.
Psalms 16: 11. Spiritual transference.
