Mining processes on the land have various effects on the communities, both in the positive an in the negative. Significantly, mining has contributed to the exemplary financial performance of the countries or the communities where the mining sites are situated. Conversely, extraction has been known to have a long-lasting environmental degradative effect. For instance, large tracts of land are left ugly in the mining processes such as in the case of the Navajo Nation. The proponents of the idea of the purchase of a coal mine from the Australian based company, BHP Billiton explained that the investment is good news to the inhabitants of the area and may lead to the financial gain of the community now and in the future. The opponents of the purchase idea claim that despite the coal mine is an investment to the Navajo nation; it exposes the community to the dangers of environmental pollution. Clay (2014) fails to establish the various advantages of the coal mine to the immediate neighborhood in the arguments provided.
The purpose of writing the article regarding the purchase of the coal mine for the Navajo nation is to the various advantages and disadvantages that the coal mine has to the community. Conclusively, the author terms it as a plan that may not safeguard the livelihoods of the tribesmen at Navajo nation in the United States of America. In explaining the purpose, the author uses the ethos persuasive strategy to ensure the audience believes in his thinking by using the various analytical approaches such as focusing on both the pros and cons of the coal mine in the society. Additionally, the author uses logos to persuade the community by stating the facts such as the 7.6 million tons of coal that Navajo nation sold to FCPP in 2012 (Clay, 2014). The federal government cited the production as one of the highest emission of nitrogen compounds to the atmosphere. The author uses logos to persuade the community members to consider the emissions that have been brought about by the mine to the nation.
Delegate your assignment to our experts and they will do the rest.
The author provides an insight of the disadvantages of the coal mine to the tribes in Navajo nation, which undoubtedly outweigh its advantages to the community (Clay, 2014). Mainly, the author focuses on the community members In the Navajo nation as the audience as he explores the topic surrounding the purchase of the Navajo nation by the tribes in the area. The explanations of the same exhibit the persuasive strategies as follows. The logos appeals to the rational thinking of the audience by providing various facts that support his argument regarding the purchase of the coal mine. The writer uses ethos to provide the audience with the reasons why they must believe in his case. For instance, he plainly states the reasons why he is against the coal mine purchase. Pathos is used to persuade the people of the nation why the purchase of the coal mine with the claims of improving the financial standing of the tribes is a bad idea.
In conclusion, the author of the article talking about the dilemmatic approach to the purchase of the coal mine by the Navajo nation claims that the overall effect of the coal mine in the community is a problem to the people. With the various skills in persuasion and the use of strategies such as ethos, pathos, and logos, the author comes up with a captivating article regarding the issue and can argue against the positive contribution of the coal mine to Navajo nation (Clay, 2014). Once stated as one of the most significant contributors of nitrogenous emissions in the USA, the coal mine is set to have pollution effects on the local people soon.
References
Clay, R. F. (2014). Tribe at a Crossroads: The Navajo Nation Purchases a Coal Mine.
Environmental Health Perspectives , 122 (4), A104.
